As of January 18, 2026, the landscape of American finance is undergoing a seismic shift that few saw coming four years ago. Polymarket, once the "offshore pariah" of the prediction market world, has successfully executed a multi-step regulatory maneuver to return to the United States. Following a period of exile that began with a CFTC settlement in 2022, the platform is now aggressively positioning itself as a regulated domestic powerhouse, challenging the current market leader, Kalshi, for dominance over the American retail trader.
The stakes for this "homecoming" are reflected in the massive capital flows and internal meta-markets currently being tracked by analysts. While Kalshi currently commands a significant 66% share of the U.S. regulated volume—driven largely by its integration with Robinhood Markets (NASDAQ: HOOD)—Polymarket’s re-entry is being viewed by traders as a potential "regime change" event. Market participants are currently betting on whether Polymarket’s deeper liquidity and aggressive 0.01% fee structure will allow it to overtake Kalshi in total U.S. monthly volume before the end of Q2 2026.
The Market: What's Being Predicted
The primary focus for traders right now isn't just the geopolitical events Polymarket is famous for, but the "market of markets": Polymarket’s own performance against its regulated rivals. On decentralized data platforms like Dune Analytics and specialized forecasting sites like Manifold Markets, "market share" contracts are trading at a fever pitch. Traders are currently pricing in a 45% probability that Polymarket will surpass Kalshi’s domestic volume by June 2026. This is a significant jump from the 15% probability seen in early 2025, before the QCEX acquisition was finalized.
Resolution of these markets depends on official volume reporting from the CFTC and clearinghouse data. The competition is essentially a "war of models." Kalshi has built a massive moat through a brokerage-first approach, leveraging the 24 million users on the Robinhood (NASDAQ: HOOD) platform. Polymarket, meanwhile, is betting on its superior global brand and its new "managed rails" infrastructure. The liquidity in these meta-markets has reached record highs, with over $50 million currently "at stake" in various contracts tracking the growth of regulated event contracts in the U.S.
Why Traders Are Betting
The bullish sentiment surrounding Polymarket’s return is anchored in two major milestones from late 2025. First was the $112 million acquisition of QCEX (the holding company for QCX LLC and QC Clearing LLC) in July. This was a strategic "legalization via acquisition" that granted Polymarket a Designated Contract Market (DCM) license and a Derivatives Clearing Organization (DCO) license. By purchasing these licenses, Polymarket bypassed years of federal red tape. This was followed by a massive $2 billion investment from the Intercontinental Exchange (NYSE: ICE), the parent company of the New York Stock Exchange, which valued Polymarket at $9 billion and signaled that institutional heavyweights were ready to back the platform’s domestic play.
Furthermore, a pivotal "no-action letter" from the CFTC in September 2025 provided the regulatory air cover Polymarket needed. The letter offered relief from certain swap data reporting requirements, effectively treating Polymarket’s event contracts as regulated financial derivatives. Traders are also reacting to Polymarket’s aggressive pricing; while Kalshi and Interactive Brokers (NASDAQ: IBKR) charge fees that can reach 1%, Polymarket has entered the U.S. with a 0.01% fee for its beta users. This "fee war" is expected to attract high-frequency traders who have previously been sidelined by the costs of regulated domestic platforms.
Broader Context and Implications
Polymarket’s shift from an "offshore" crypto-native platform to a regulated U.S. entity marks the end of the "wild west" era of prediction markets. In 2024, Polymarket was frequently criticized for operating outside U.S. law, but its 2025 transformation has turned it into a cornerstone of the broader financial ecosystem. Its data is now integrated into the Bloomberg Terminal and serves as a primary sentiment indicator for major news outlets. This institutionalization is having a cooling effect on traditional gambling stocks like DraftKings (NASDAQ: DKNG) and Flutter Entertainment (NYSE: FLUT), as investors realize that prediction markets offer a more efficient, "peer-to-peer" way to hedge risk and speculate on outcomes.
However, the return has not been without friction. In early January 2026, a controversial trade involving the capture of Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro sparked allegations of insider trading, leading to the introduction of the "Public Integrity in Financial Prediction Markets Act of 2026" by Rep. Ritchie Torres. This legislation aims to ban federal officials from trading on these platforms. While some see this as a hurdle, veteran market participants argue that such regulation is a sign of maturity; if the government feels the need to regulate who can trade, it is essentially admitting that these markets have become as influential as the stock or bond markets.
What to Watch Next
The immediate focus is on the "Full Public Launch" slated for late February 2026. Polymarket currently operates an invite-only beta for U.S. residents, but a wide-scale opening—reportedly to a waitlist of over 500,000 users—is expected to coincide with the Super Bowl and the primary season of the upcoming midterm elections. A successful, glitch-free launch would likely see the "market share" odds swing heavily in Polymarket's favor.
Additionally, keep an eye on the legal battlegrounds at the state level. While the CFTC has granted federal approval, states like Nevada and Connecticut have issued cease-and-desist orders, arguing that sports-related event contracts constitute unlicensed gambling. The resolution of this "federal vs. state" conflict will determine the ultimate ceiling for Polymarket and Kalshi. If the industry can secure federal preemption—a scenario currently trading at an 81% probability on Manifold—the path to becoming a trillion-dollar asset class will be wide open.
Bottom Line
Polymarket’s $112 million bet on QCEX and its subsequent regulatory pivot represent one of the most successful "second acts" in fintech history. By January 2026, the platform has successfully shed its reputation as a legal outlier and re-emerged as a sophisticated, CFTC-regulated exchange. The backing of the Intercontinental Exchange (NYSE: ICE) provides the institutional credibility and technical infrastructure necessary to compete with the Kalshi-Robinhood (NASDAQ: HOOD) alliance.
Ultimately, the real winners of this rivalry are the traders. The "war of models" is driving fees down, liquidity up, and transparency to new heights. Prediction markets are no longer a niche curiosity for crypto enthusiasts; they are becoming the primary mechanism for how the world prices the probability of the future. Whether Polymarket can truly "dethrone" Kalshi in the U.S. remains to be seen, but the era of regulated, mass-market forecasting has officially arrived.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial or betting advice. Prediction market participation may be subject to legal restrictions in your jurisdiction.
PredictStreet focuses on covering the latest developments in prediction markets.
Visit the PredictStreet website at https://www.predictstreet.ai/.
