The Deal
Pipeline published the following article, which became available online on
October 23, 2009:
Proxy
firms side with Steel Partners in Adaptec fight
by
Anthony Noto
Updated
03:49 PM, Oct-23-2009 ET
New York
hedge fund Steel Partners Ltd. got some heavy reinforcements in its battle to
force Adaptec Inc. to sell its assets when two major proxy advisory firms
expressed their dissatisfaction with the direction the data storage company and
its management are heading.
Both
RiskMetrics Group Inc. and Proxy Governance Inc. support Steel Partners’ request
that Adaptec CEO Sundi Sundaresh be removed because, as RiskMetrics put it in an
Oct. 22 report, “dissidents have made a valid case for greater management and
board oversight.”
Through a
series of letters, filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission, minority
Adaptec shareholder Steel Partners has stated that it not only wants Sundaresh
removed, but is also pushing the Milpitas, Calif., company to sell its
assets.
For its
part, Adaptec has been busy trying to rally others around its contention that
Steel Partners, which holds 11% of Adaptec’s common stock, has no viable plan
for the company, distorts Sundaresh’s accomplishments and has engaged in
“counterproductive behavior in the boardroom.”
RiskMetrics
and Proxy Governance join Steel Partners and another Adaptec shareholder,
Arcadia Capital Advisors LLC, in their discontent over Sundaresh’s and legacy
director Robert Loarie’s “horrendous track record of stockholder value
destruction.”
In an
Oct. 1 filing with the SEC, Steel Partners contends that Adaptec’s net revenue
has declined 70% to about $114.8 million for the 2009 fiscal year ended Sept.
30, compared to $344 million for the same period in 2006.
Steel
Partners also blamed Adaptec’s directors for diminishing the shareholder’s
influence by “blocking the democratic process,” adding that it “will not sit
idly by and allow the minority directors to be kicked to the curb.”
Earlier
this month, Arcadia, which owns less than 5% of Adaptec’s stock, wrote a letter
to Adaptec’s board requesting it reorganize under new leadership, protect
existing cash and initiate a stock repurchase program.
But
Adaptec waited for the RiskMetrics and Proxy Governance actions to fire back at
the dissenters, noting in a response on Thursday that it’s puzzled by the
recommendations.
“The
bottom line for stockholders concerned about the value of their investment
should be this: they can choose between a [b]oard majority and a CEO who have
track records of exploring all options objectively—and of preserving capital and
developing a strategic path toward significant value creation—or they can choose
a desperate hedge fund with a dismal recent investment track record that offers
no path toward value creation but proposes only steps that could leave Adaptec
without competent technology management and subject to disposition at fire-sale
prices,” said Douglas E. Van Houweling, the chairman of Adaptec’s governance and
nominating committee, in a statement.
If
Sundaresh and Loarie were to resign, two of Adaptec’s nine board seats would be
vacant. Three seats are already held by Steel Partners.
One proxy
advisor in Adaptec’s corner is Glass, Lewis & Co., which released a
report Oct. 12 recommending that “stockholders reject all of the proposals
solicited by Steel Partners II LP,” the Steel Partners subsidiary that owns the
Adaptec stake, and not sell the company at this time.
The
Adaptec board has agreed to evaluate all options, and has stated it wishes to
increase shareholder value, even hiring an investment adviser to review the
possibility of a sale, but that was earlier this year. The name of the adviser
has not been disclosed, and the process has bogged down because of Adaptec’s
fear of an asset fire sale.
Adaptec
contends that Steel Partners favors a fire sale, but a spokesman for the hedge
fund denied that. “Of course we don’t want to conduct a fire sale of assets,” he
said.
Adaptec
directors earlier this year also asked shareholders not to respond to Steel
Partners solicitations, because “just as Adaptec is gaining momentum... Steel
Partners II LP, wants to relinquish this hard-won progress,” according to SEC
filings.
Adaptec
in an Oct. 21 announcement said it expects to see a net cash balance of $382
million at the end of the first quarter in 2010, which would be a $142 million
improvement over the first quarter balance in 2006.
According
to an Adaptec spokesman, Steel Partners wants to sell all of Adaptec’s assets
and use the proceeds to acquire a bank.
“Adaptec’s
priority would be to continue the turnaround,” he added.
© Deal
Pipeline 2009. All rights reserved.